PDA

View Full Version : Critique's corner - the Next Generation


Recess
28th September 2006, 08:43 AM
Hey folks.

Ok. Now that I've finished writing the book (just got to proof it at the end of Oct, and then I just wait until December for the release, all the time cacking myself that people won't like it) I'm looking to put more time into trying to improve my rather lacklustre photography technique. (it still annoys me that the only good shot I've taken and posted on here was with Julie's £100 pentax snapper, rather than the £700 DigiSLR...

One option is books. CHeck - reading them as we speak.

Another option is a course - due to odd work times though, I feel quite reluctant to sign up for something that I can't be sure I can make (I'm in here till 9pm most evenings, and then I just want to go home and sit with Julie and the cats for a while)

So, the last option is to take shots based on what I can glean from books and your comments here, and the book stuff and post here to see how I'm getting on.

Why am I posting this in here? Well - I was wondering if there's any point in trying to make a 'Virtual Photography' lesson thing here. Kinda like combining the competition and the critique forum together. Suggestions are given - like 'Take a shot of a stream' (so not as open as a suggestion like 'Water' or 'Movement' in the comp. forum) and then the newbies, like me can post to get comments.

I guess the flaw to this is that it would need someone to actually take control of it, and maybe I'd be the only person posting into it too - but I was just thinking about how the incredible resource of the great and helpful photographers on here could be harnessed to help the not so great ones.

(So, in case you skipped all of that to see if there was a point hidden somewher, all neatly summarised at the end, what I'm suggesting is:

Once a week (or fortnight, but week would be nice) - a basic but set scene needs to be shot - to be posted here for review and comment in view to improvement.

I dunno, too much? It's a fair bit of time it would take to consider a scene and then comment on it.

Ah hell, it's just a suggestion.

Have a nice day.

J

marty
28th September 2006, 08:52 AM
Recess are you ok? did you take your medication today? first there was the bear pictures, then a thread where you seem to be talking to yourself, are you really that bored?:confused:

Recess
28th September 2006, 08:58 AM
Thanks for caring... :grin:

Too much time on my hands now, too much coffee, too much to do, and too little time spent reading over the things I type.

It's not boredom - it's work avoidance.

J

marty
28th September 2006, 09:04 AM
*cracks the whip*
JUMP OFF THE FORUM RIGHT NOW BOY, AND GET BACK TO WORK, NO PUT THAT EMPTY CUP DOWN, I SAID SIT, or I'll send Bindii over to deal with you....

Stemmy
28th September 2006, 09:06 AM
Yes the idea sounds great - we already have the weekly challenge thread that Waif administers. maybe just a bit of modification is all thats needed.

Waif
28th September 2006, 09:27 AM
Sounds like a great idea..... Maybe the winner could 'set a scene' for the next challenge?

StuG
28th September 2006, 10:13 AM
Sounds like a good idea Recess, especially as i didn't manage to get on a course myself cos they were all fully booked.

Recess
28th September 2006, 10:34 AM
Yes the idea sounds great - we already have the weekly challenge thread that Waif administers. maybe just a bit of modification is all thats needed.

Yeah - it's like an 'anti-challenge' though, for those of us who want to post a structured shot for a scope to improve, and then ultimately take something that's good enough to put in the challenge thread - a development thread rather than an excellence thread.

(Don't tell marty I'm here - she'll shout at me again...)

J

Waif
28th September 2006, 10:38 AM
I could run two challenges if thats prefered? SOMEONE make a decision and let me know! :grin:

Tim
28th September 2006, 10:45 AM
Sounds like a good idea.. I think it would be best to keep it seperate from the comp.. Set up up a seperate thread for it where a subject is chosen, those interested go and shoot it and then they're shots can be deconstructed and built on... I like it and will moderate it if you want me to Waif.. Let me know..

Waif
28th September 2006, 10:58 AM
Sure thing Tim....

I did put up a poll to see if people wanted the Challenge changed, but I'll take that down and we can run one each.

I like the idea of both so hey, its a free world - lets do both.

Nice one Recess. :grin:

Recess
28th September 2006, 12:51 PM
Gee, shucks, thanks.

I look forward to posting in it. Hopefully others will too!

J

Kirsty
28th September 2006, 03:55 PM
Hey!

Whats your book called/about?

Recess
28th September 2006, 05:47 PM
Oh, sorry - I thought everyone knew.

It's DJing for Dummies - which I think is self explanatory. It's out in December, and I finished writing it on Monday. I get to proof the images that are in it at the end of the month, but apart from that I don't get to see it again until the first of December - when I hold the finished book in my hands and absolutely cack my shorts!!

http://www.djrecess.co.uk/forumimages/djcover.jpg

Cool as hell though - I keep looking at it and thinking 'Huh... that's MY name....'

Thanks for asking though.

John

daddy_cool
28th September 2006, 09:12 PM
Firstly, Looks like you been busy with the book, should be a great sucess for you.

Secondly, as for your sugestion for the forum, i think it's a great idea and i would certainly be up for posting to get help with my photography.

Tim
29th September 2006, 04:10 PM
Nice one on the book John.. Well impressed.. Must get it when it comes out.. Keep us posted.. As for the new thread I'll get to work on that..

Bindii
29th September 2006, 04:40 PM
Sounds like a good idea.. I think it would be best to keep it seperate from the comp.. Set up up a seperate thread for it where a subject is chosen, those interested go and shoot it and then they're shots can be deconstructed and built on... I like it and will moderate it if you want me to Waif.. Let me know..

I missed recesses thread....sorry dude....but I do have a life sometimes....ok I dont really have a life but it sounds better than saying I'm slack and stuff..

anyway I think its a wonderful idea....

and the way Tim has described it sounds like it would work really well...

and to think I've always said Tims not just a cute ass....;)c

Bindii
29th September 2006, 04:41 PM
Oh, sorry - I thought everyone knew.

It's DJing for Dummies - which I think is self explanatory. It's out in December, and I finished writing it on Monday. I get to proof the images that are in it at the end of the month, but apart from that I don't get to see it again until the first of December - when I hold the finished book in my hands and absolutely cack my shorts!!


Cool as hell though - I keep looking at it and thinking 'Huh... that's MY name....'

Thanks for asking though.

John

Oooh....I know someone else famous....

:)

Congrats!